Who is Canadian?

by Peter Worthington, QMI Agency

Toronto Sun, July 8,

http://www.torontosun.com/2012/07/06/second-world-war-not-over-for-would-be-canadian

It’s pretty hard to believe that Citizenship Minister Jason Kenney would tell the daughter of a Canadian war veteran in Vancouver that her father, who was born in Canada and had never set foot out of the country until it asked him to go to war, was not, in fact, a Canadian citizen but a British subject.

Insulting, degrading ... and wrong.

This is a theme Kenney and Citizenship and Immigration (CIC) have been pushing for some time. It’s not just a slip of the tongue or a misunderstanding, but a considered view to which the government is apparently committed.

Or, as Jason Kenney told Jackie Scott, who confronted him: “(Soldiers) are heroes, but at the time they were British subjects.” He said prior to 1947 there was no such thing as a “Canadian” citizen.

Some eight years ago when Jackie Scott was denied a Canadian passport, she was told she was not Canadian — despite working here, paying taxes, voting, having children and grandchildren who are Canadian.

She was born out of wedlock in Britain to a Canadian soldier and a British mother, who married after Jackie’s birth and came to Canada. Jackie never had doubts that she was a citizen, until CIC told her she wasn’t.

Jason Kenney elaborated that none of the Canadian soldiers killed in First and Second World Wars — more than 100,000 killed in Canada’s name, including 3,598 at Vimy Ridge — were citizens. They were British subjects. Why, in the name of sanity, is Prime Minister Stephen Harper letting such nonsense be disseminated by his government? He’s got to know it is wrong, yet he tolerates abuse to the memories of Canadians killed in war — as symbolized by the continuing meanness to Jackie Scott and hundreds like her who think they are Canadian but are ensnared in bureaucratic red tape that denies them citizenship.

While feeling hurt and abandoned, Jackie Scott is more outraged that her father is being discredited.

We should all feel indignant.

A couple of months ago I confronted Jason Kenney with Jackie Scott’s case, and he implied that it, and others like it, would be resolved in the near future. One wonders.

What is inexplicable is how he and CIC apparatchiks have the nerve to say there was no such thing as a Canadian citizen before 1947 — a curious magic date.

Under the British North America Act in 1867, Canada became a separate country, and citizenship was determined by the father, including “married women, minors, lunatics and idiots.” Children born in wedlock were considered property (and nationality) of the father; out of wedlock, property of the mother.

That was then, this is now.

Some aspects of Canada’s sloppy Citizenship Act were corrected in 2009, but up to 5% have slipped through the cracks and are still denied citizenship. Jason Kenney knows this, but still has the effrontery to say that Canadians who went to war were not Canadian citizens.

Like Second World War veteran Guy Valliere who died a stateless “Lost Canadian” because CIC never got around to his case, Jackie Scott fears that at age 66 she’ll be dead before she’s confirmed a genuine Canadian like the rest of her family. I rather like Jason Kenney, but refusing to recognize Canadian citizenship prior to 1947 reveals an unforgivable flaw.

For God’s sake, do the right thing for a change.

Back